Ballot Recounts Ordered Amid Public Scrutiny in Canada's 2025 Federal Election

By Small Town Productions | May 10, 2025

In the aftermath of Canada's tight and historic 2025 federal election, judicial recounts have been ordered in four key ridings following razor-thin margins and growing public scrutiny over the integrity of the results. These recounts are not just a formality—they are a response to calls for transparency from voters, candidates, and political observers alike.

Rising Public Concern

With such close outcomes in several districts and a minority government hanging in the balance, concerns about vote-counting accuracy quickly emerged. While Elections Canada affirmed its confidence in the original tabulations, the closeness of the vote triggered automatic recounts in some ridings and judicial reviews in others. Judges have stated these actions are essential to uphold public trust in Canadian democracy.

“Given the closeness of the result and the public interest in ensuring confidence in our electoral system, a recount is both warranted and necessary.” - Justice Marie-Pauline Dugré, Terrebonne recount

Ridings Under Judicial Recount

1. Terrebonne, Quebec

Initial winner: Liberal Tatiana Auguste

Certified winner: Bloc incumbent Nathalie Sinclair-Desgagné (by 44 votes)

Status: Recount ordered due to conflicting results and tight margin.

2. Milton East–Halton Hills South, Ontario

Lead: Liberal Kristina Tesser Derksen by 29 votes

Status: Recount scheduled for May 13 after a formal petition and public concern.

3. Terra Nova–The Peninsulas, Newfoundland & Labrador

Winner: Liberal Anthony Germain by 12 votes

Status: Automatic recount begins May 12 due to narrow margin.

4. Windsor–Tecumseh–Lakeshore, Ontario

Winner: Conservative Kathy Borrelli by 77 votes

Status: Judicial recount granted following a Liberal petition and procedural concerns.

Implications for Parliament

With the Liberal Party holding 168 seats—four shy of a majority—the final outcome of these recounts could be pivotal. Even one riding shifting could influence coalition dynamics or confidence motions in the House of Commons.

A Transparent Process

Though some view recounts as signs of a flawed system, experts and judges alike argue they’re proof of a healthy democracy. Judicial oversight and transparency in the process help ensure the results reflect voters’ true intentions.

Thank You for Standing Up for Democracy

At Small Town Productions, we want to extend a heartfelt thank you to everyone who has shared this story, raised awareness, and spoken up for transparency and accountability. Your voices matter.

By staying informed, asking questions, and demanding fairness, you're helping uphold the democratic values that define true Canadian patriotism. Whether you voted, volunteered, or simply paid attention—thank you for standing tall for what’s right.

Together, we strengthen not just our communities, but our country.

Keep watching, keep questioning, and keep believing in the power of everyday Canadians.

To keep updated with our latest news articles by having them sent straight to your email please visit www.smalltownproductions.org/signup

Link for Donations

We are solely independent with our news and our main source of funding is the amazing donations provided by readers like yourself to the link below. If you value non-biased and truthful news based on facts, please anything helps us keep you informed and in the know

https://square.link/u/3N7yXqU6